No. To me, it has the same problems as all the other Uncharted games.
-> Wonky shooting with bland guns
-> Easy climb-sections take up 60% of the game. Not very engaging gameplay imo since it's hard to fail at these things.
-> Boring enemies, "meh" melee combat.
-> A story akin to Indiana Jones only with less interesting characters and a boring villain.
-> Easy puzzles
What I did like:
-> Shiny graphics
-> Some of the chase-sequences
Overall:
To me, it's better than uncharted 2, but that's only due to this game not having such an annoying final boss nor does it have the same BS-enemy hordes. Seriously, I can't stress enough how annoying and shitty the final boss of Uncharted 2. If it didn't have that, it would the best game in the series without question.
It's an 8 out of 10. Fun while it lasts, but doesn't leave any impact nor want for a sequel.
(Just my opinion, if you adore these games: good on you)