Kill Your Babies!
-
@DeweyDTruman said in Kill Your Babies!:
Portal 2 simply isn't as good as the first game generally speaking
uh what? It expanded on everything and actually had a decent lengthy campaign with better writing, a better ending and an awesome super long coop campaign.
Killing my darlings is fine, but doing it with a boldfaced lie is not okay! Shame :bell:
-
@GoshGollyGee said in Kill Your Babies!:
Love you, Bioshock, but a game that screws up its ending as badly as you did does not deserve to be called the greatest ever made.
What did BioShock do at the end to deserve such treatment?
-
@Hoken said in Kill Your Babies!:
@DeweyDTruman said in Kill Your Babies!:
Portal 2 simply isn't as good as the first game generally speaking
uh what? It expanded on everything and actually had a decent lengthy campaign with better writing, a better ending and an awesome super long coop campaign.
Killing my darlings is fine, but doing it with a boldfaced lie is not okay! Shame :bell:
More isn't inherently better. I thought the first game was the perfect length, it got in and out before it wore out its welcome whereas Portal 2 kinda dragged. It's not a terrible game, but I wouldn't call it better than the first one.
-
Strawpoll, if you want to vote which baby survives.
-
If Mario doesn't win, I will kill your actual firstborn baby.
J/k
I'll just kill your secondborn instead.
-
@Krauser So if I have no children, I'm fine then, right?
-
@Nillend Yeah then you'll be good.
-
@Krauser Phew :D
-
Come on Mario!
-
@benoit489 said in Kill Your Babies!:
What did BioShock do at the end to deserve such treatment?
The game completely loses its momentum after the famous twist. The final boss is less than stellar as well.
It's not enough to keep it from being a classic, but I'd say that "the best game ever created in our parallel universe without question" should be 10/10 for its entire duration.
That might just be me, though.
-
MGS2 needs to win, it is undeniably the greatest game ever made.
-
This post is deleted!
-
@Nillend said in Kill Your Babies!:
Strawpoll, if you want to vote which baby survives.
Thanks for taking that initiative here @Nillend, the straw poll was a great idea. My heart is still trying to recover from Bioshock being knocked out so early.
-
@Nillend Do I vote for the winner, or which one I want to kill?
-
@Thunder-Lobster It's intended to vote for who you want to survive (I voted wrong because I didn't read). I'll randomly hop on tomorrow and declare a winner. Oh, the tension!
-
@Tristan said in Kill Your Babies!:
MGS2 needs to win, it is undeniably the greatest game ever made.
It's not even the best game in the series. Galaxy should win because it's arguably the best Mario game.
-
@TheOhrenberger
But it IS the best game in the series, and of all time!
-
Should our alternate universe match this universe? Perhaps we should have killed off our favorite game that remained.
-
Alright everyone... we've had enough time to deliberate. There shall only be one fantastic game in our new universe and its name is... Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty!
I'm okay with this beating out Super Mario Galaxy solely based on the fact that after Galaxy, Nintendo has played it very safe and not delivered a Mario game even close to its quality. Metal Gear on the other hand... whoo, what a legend of a series.
This was fun though! I'm thinking about trying again with another list soon, maybe out of a specific genre.
-
I've... never played a Metal Gear game...
