Hall of Greats Compendium

  • @Sentinel-Beach I don't think RE4 will get in before RE2, so we shall all likely continue to be weird 😊

  • @Inustar I don't know. All of them love RE4, even Kyle, whereas I think the only one passionate enough to champion RE2 would be Huber. RE4 is just one of those eventual "No duh"s, lol.

  • @Minamik I look forward to seeing which RE gets in first, and how long it takes.

  • Silent Hill 2 is making it in before any Resident Evil game.

    Bold prediction. In bold.

  • @SabotageTheTruth Well, not like anyone is going to go to bat for Fatal Frame. :(

  • @SabotageTheTruth every Zelda, Mario and MGS game will make it in before Silent Hill.

    Even bolder prediction... so bold it had to be struck out.

    Though realistically I think at least one of each will probably get another in before Silent Hill.

  • Great list, great show, great patreon. Thanks for putting this up.

  • Nothing like another Hall of Greats for me to realize how little I have in common with popular gaming tastes. :D

  • Awesome list so far, i need Uber to brute force Resident Evil 2 in though XD

  • I couldn't help but feel a great disconnect yesterday, I played Chrono Trigger for the first time a couple of years ago, and while I agree that it was very well made and it doens't really have any clear weak points, I didn't find it astounding or incredible in any way, still seeing how it is a classic and all I see how it belongs there, it just seems blown out of proportion to me.

    Pokemon on the other hand .... Yuck.

  • Chrono Trigger / 3pts 2pts 3pts 1pt 3pts 3pts 3pts 3pts = 21 pts
    Pokémon Red & Blue / 2pts 3pts 1pt 2pts = 8 pts
    Grand Theft Auto III / 2pts 2pts 2pts 1pt = 7 pts
    Mega Man X / 2pts 3pts 1pt 1pt = 7 pts
    Streets of Rage 2 / 1pt 1pt 2pts = 4 pts
    Super Mario Maker / 3pts = 3 pts
    Journey / 2pts = 2 pts
    Myst / 1p 1pt = 2 pts
    The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim / = 0 pts

    I felt like going through the points again after watching the HoG evening, because CT's points sounded someway insane, but no, they were right, Brad was right. The game got votes from everyone except from Don. I was sure it would be Pokemon and GTA 3 that would go through until Brad arrived at the last moment with his behemoth. Poor Brandon, he felt so sure in Cup of Jones and all. Well, it's only a matter of time that he gets something in. I'm seeing RDR in the near future, for instance. :)

    edsortiz can finetune the results for his picture and opening post up there.

  • Updated!
    Thank you all

  • Great thread! :)

    There's something wrong about the points for Q1 2017 though, because they total 55 instead of 54 as they should.

  • @Axass You mean Q2 right? Yea... Ill check it out again

  • @Axass Found it, it was the votes for World of Warcraft, it was "1" instead of "2". Blame my sub-conscience of months in hours of playing that game. Thanks for finding that out!

  • Another Hall of Greats in the books! Kind of felt the "Survivor" style voting and reveals kind dragged out the end a little bit, but still a great stream! Super stoked Pokemon got in and a little bummed Super Mario Maker got banned, but I've got a personal favorite still on the ban list so it's something I'm used to.

    Also, really awesome that the hall of greats .com url brings people right to this thread!

  • @Brannox I dunno man I thought the survivor voting was the best part.

  • @Brannox I loved it. It makes it much more personal to be in on every ally's internal deliberations.

  • I also liked the new voting system in front of the camera, really nice to hear their reasons now. The way they then revealed the results for themselves could still need some tinkering, though. Just not sure how.

  • @DeweyDTruman @Minamik Personally, while I don't have a problem with each Ally giving their reasons, I felt it just took too long. Bring back the blind voting and while the games go from least to most votes, then the Allies could give their reasons. Keeps the speediness of the old format while retaining the personal opinions and reasons behind why Allies voted the way the did.