The Game Awards 2017. Who has your vote?



  • @Sentinel-Beach said in The Game Awards 2017. Who has your vote?:

    Just hoping that we here could have our own GOTY voting in January then, like EZA themselves are going to do it this time.

    If everyone is fine with it, I'm planning to organize a GOTY voting like for 2016 and 2015, around mid-January. With more than 5 nominations allowed, because this year is just impossible :D

    @michemagius Yup, I think it's going to be a 4 or 5 horse race for our GOTY this year, really hard to predict which one will come out on top. I'm excited!!



  • I don't mind the nominees and categories at all but Yakuza 0 probably has the best narrative I've ever played in a video game, yet it wasn't nominated at all.

    I'm also surprised they nominated Nier Automata under Best RPG (which is fine) but didn't mention it under Best Action Game.

    Best narrative needs to go to Nier Automata. It played with what players expect in a video game and spun it on its head which provided unique gameplay moments as well. They even provide detailed context for the UI. It's a no brainer to me.



  • I really don't care about that show but in any case, Persona 5 takes any eligible vote for me



  • Let's not forget, EVERY nominee came from the judges panel, which you can look up here

    If you're wondering why any game didn't make any category, these are the outlets/influencers who nominated games. From what I gather, everyone selects an unknown amount of nominees per category, which are then aggregated down to the five (or six in case of a tie) nominees who held the most votes.

    SO: Among ALL of these outlets, most if not all picked Zelda, Mario, Persona, Horizon, and PUBG to be GOTY, regardless of ranking. Now that the nominees have been announced, all of these same judges will probably have, if not very, VERY soon, vote for which nominee they feel should each respective category.

    It is ENTIRELY possible that a handful nominated several games like Yakuza, Nier, or Hellblade for GOTY, but did not get enough votes from their peers to bump out say Persona or PUBG. THIS IS ENTIRELY CONJECTURE ON MY PART. I do not know how the system works. This is just the only conclusion that made sense to me.



  • @Axel I'm good with whatever you decide. You did an awesome job before, and I look forward to participating once again! If you are going beyond the five nominations, I can only provide seven total. I honestly believe keeping it five should make it a more earned list. And I'm saying that knowing full well only one, MAYBE two, of my picks will place.



  • @Brannox

    What you are saying makes complete sense. I doubt they interview the industry panel. They also likely submit a vote. I'm surprised that Yakuza 0 didn't make best narrative which makes me wonder how many people on the panel played it. It's actually shocking to me.

    What I'm curious about is if they had guidelines for the genre categories. I wonder if Nier didn't make the cut in action game or if it didn't qualify due to their classifications.



  • @DIPSET Again, I can only speculate, although I do feel like the judges had some liberty in what to nominate where.

    And while it may surprise you, it doesn't to me. I think Yakuza is following Persona's track. Persona has really become mainstream since Persona 4 Golden. Now that people such as yourself are singing Yakuza 0's praises, who isn't to say when Yakuza 6 launches next year, it has more of a presence?

    Please also keep in mind who is on the panel. Easy Allies and other influencers? I believe they know of Yakuza's quality. But the big named mainstream not primarily associated with industry (Entertainment Weekly, USA Today, TIME) probably don't focus on franchises that are currently more niche than others like Yakuza, Nier, and Nioh. Once more, this is entirely conjecture, and it could come out one of those three was the only one to nominate Yakuza 0. Shrugs shoulders



  • First off, yeah i hate that PUBG is nominated for GOTY or nominated for anything at all. I don't care how popular it is, it's not an official release. But whatever.

    This was very hard voting for me. The best year in gaming of all time. It took a while to decide between Zelda and Persona. Good thing they both came out at the same time. I love them both a lot but...I voted Persona 5. It just stuck with me longer than Zelda, i kept thinking and missing it. Whereas for BotW it was just, well I'll get back to it with the DLC so any thoughts were dismissed. Whereas, I still think about the characters in Persona 5. I still think about things in BotW too like some puzzles and just exploring the world. But one had to be chosen for GOTY.

    I did vote for BotW for Best Action game. Best Music was the hardest, harder than GOTY. Cuphead, P5 and Nier Automata have outstanding scores/soundtracks. I went with Nier. Mostly because I gave votes to Cuphead and P5 in other categories. But that's not a good thing to do, if something is the the best, it's the best. Nier is the game i played more recently so it's not even fair that it's fresh in my mind. But I honestly hold the music of these 3 games on the same pedestal of greatness so..yeah there's my poor justification. All 3 really deserve it.

    I didn't vote for Odyssey because i don't have a Switch yet :( else it would probably sweep my choices.

    Also it's weird how P5 was omitted from Best Narrative and how both P5 AND Nier Automata were omitted from the Games for Impact category. I'd argue both of those games are very thought provoking and Persona is absolutely pro-social.



  • @RayneSol I know right? I was really puzzled that Persona didn't make best narrative, and both P5 and Nier didn't make games for impact. I think the nominees listed probably all have great stories (I can't really tell I didn't play all of them), but I think both P5 and Nier have really strong stories. I'd argue that they're probably one of the strongest aspects of those games.



  • @michemagius Yeah. I say this as I finish Route C of Nier haha, it's great. In that category I think I voted for What Remains of Edith Finch. I didn't play it but I watched all of Huber's playthrough, it really hooked me. Maybe the jury felt P5 and Nier already held so many of the more prominent categories so they picked more less known yet still worthy titles for that category, probably.



  • @RayneSol I guess. I would just feel better about it If I felt P5 or Nier were clear front runners for the categories they were nominated in. I feel that either Persona 5 or Nier should win in the categories they are nominated for, but with tough competition there's no real guarantee that they'll win. It's gonna be hard for them to beat Mario, Cuphead, Zelda, or FFXV, which I feel all appeal more to a broader audience. Not that those games are better than Nier or P5, I just think more people played them.



  • @michemagius I agree that P5 and Nier are a bit more niche. I'm honestly happily surprised to see Persona 5 nominated for GOTY. But for me, BotW is about just as good, sometimes better, I really loved playing both of them this year. So if Zelda wins, i'd still be happy but that's more expected than if P5 wins. Even if Mario wins i'd be happy, love Mario. I'll play Odyssey one day.



  • @RayneSol I get where you're coming from. I wasn't as crazy about Zelda as most other people but I recognize that it's a very well made game and that its a big step forward for the franchise (even If I'm not super thrilled about the direction that step was in), and while I have yet to play Mario, everything I've seen of it makes me think that it's a phenomenal game. I just think P5 winning would be a really significant for JRPG's on the whole, and I do think it really deserves the win. But at the end of the day I can't say an undeserving game won GotY if Zelda or Mario take the title.



  • I will give the vote to these 2017 games:
    destiny 2
    Call of Duty: WWII
    Assassin's Creed Origins
    Mass Effect: Andromeda
    The Evil Within 2



  • Giving Best Audio or Best Performance to anything other than Hellblade will be a joke.

    Same for Ongoing Game and Warframe. One of the games on that list isn't even finished, and another is a monumental step backward compared to it's previous game. Warframe is one of the most incredible evolutions of a game I've ever seen, and it is all totally free.

    My GotY is going to Horizon though.



  • @El-Shmiablo said in The Game Awards 2017. Who has your vote?:

    One of the games on that list isn't even finished, and another is a monumental step backward compared to it's previous game.

    Last I checked Warframe still calls itself a Beta.



  • Yakuza 0 was definitely slighted. Will be curious to see if next year, Yakuza 6 with all it's improvements gets any nominations.



  • I'm cutting categories that mean nothing to me.

    From the nominations:

    GOTY: Mario Odyssey
    Direction: RE VII
    Narrative: NieR: Automata
    Art: Persona 5
    Score/Music: NieR: Automata
    Audio: RE VII
    Games for Impact: Life is Strange: Before the Storm
    Handheld: Ever Oasis
    VR/AR: RE VII
    Action: Prey
    Action Adventure: Super Mario Odyssey
    RPG: Divinity: Original Sin 2
    Family: Super Mario Odyssey
    Anticipated: Monster Hunter: World .... I guess.

    My personal picks:

    GOTY: Prey
    Direction: RE VII
    Narrative: Life is Strange: Before the Storm
    Art: Gravity Rush 2
    Score/Music: NieR: Automata
    Audio: RE VII
    Games for Impact: Life is Strange: Before the Storm
    Indie: Thimbleweed Park
    Handheld: Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana
    VR/AR: RE VII
    Action: Prey
    Action Adventure: RE VII
    RPG: Divinity: Original Sin 2
    Family: Super Mario Odyssey
    Anticipated: Fear Effect Reinvented / System Shock



  • @Sheria I was actually a bit surprised Gravity Rush 2 didn't make the Art category. That game has a very distinct and aesthetically pleasing style.



  • @Hazz3r That is semantics at this point. The "beta" has been going on for 6 years now. The game is very, very much a complete experience.
    Meanwhile PUBG has optimization issues that even beastly rigs can't always brute force.

    @michemagius Released too early in the year and too niche. Don't get me wrong I think the game is absolutely beautiful, but this has happened for years.