Guess the Metacritic (2018)



  • Using your extensive knowledge of how games are developed, who the developers and publishers are and your own experiences, you will predict these games' metacritic score! Or you know... you can blindly guess them.
    So guess the score, guess a delay, or guess a cancellation.

    Voting will close on January 15th, so good luck and have fun!

    Last of Us Part 2
    Red Dead Redemption 2
    Ni no Kuni 2
    Monster Hunter World
    Dragonball FighterZ
    Spider-Man
    God of War
    Kingdom Hearts 3
    Soul Calibur 6
    Vampyr
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night
    Metal Gear Survive
    Sea of Thieves
    Crackdown 3
    Valkyria Chronicles 4
    Detroit Become Human
    A Way Out
    Biomutant
    Travis Strikes Again
    State of Decay 2
    Left Alive
    Metro Exodus
    Mega Man 11
    Far Cry 5
    Dreams
    Anthem
    Kingdom Come Deliverance
    Days Gone
    Shenmue 3
    Yakuza 6
    Bayonetta 3

    Scoring system:
    Exact Score = 12 points
    1 point off = 9 Points
    2 points off = 8 Points
    3 points off = 7 Points
    4 points off = 6 Points
    5 points off = 5 Points
    6 points off = 4 Points
    7 points off = 3 Points
    8 points off = 2 Points
    9 points off = 1 Point
    Game is delayed to 2019 = 0 Points
    Guess a delay to 2019 = 5 Points
    Guess a cancellation = 10 points

    Other information:

    1. You can not guess a score and a delay. It's one or the other.
    2. For multiplatform games the score will be the best available. So if it's 88 on PS4 and 94 on Xbox One, then the 94 is the one that will count.
    3. There a lot of games on this list, but there are plenty I didn't add and there will likely be plenty more we don't even know about yet that will release this year. If people wanna guess other games, sure have fun but only the ones on this list will count toward this game.
    4. Everyone commend @Alex840 for coming up with this last year.
    5. You don't need to guess for all the games I guess, but why not just blindly slap a number on a game and see what happens.

    L&R and have fun with this.



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (93)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (82)
    Monster Hunter World (88)
    Dragonball FighterZ (90)
    Spider-Man (85)
    God of War (84)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delay)
    Soul Calibur 6 (88)
    Vampyr (86)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (76)
    Metal Gear Survive (78)
    Sea of Thieves (80)
    Crackdown 3 (79)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (85)
    Detroit Become Human (83)
    A Way Out (74)
    Biomutant (Delay)
    Travis Strikes Again (79)
    State of Decay 2 (81)
    Left Alive (Delay)
    Metro Exodus (85)
    Mega Man 11 (80)
    Far Cry 5 (84)
    Dreams (78)
    Anthem (Delay)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (82)
    Days Gone (80)
    Shenmue 3 (82)
    Yakuza 6 (83)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delay)

    Thanks for doing this!

    There's quite a few tricky ones, I tried to be more optimistic with scores than for 2017, but also be ruthless with delays. Kinda wanted to pick Cancelled for Crackdown 3 but I choose to believe!



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (95)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (85)
    Monster Hunter World (91)
    Dragonball FighterZ (85)
    Spider-Man (91)
    God of War (91)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (80)
    Soul Calibur 6 (77)
    Vampyr (77)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (79)
    Metal Gear Survive (85)
    Sea of Thieves (72)
    Crackdown 3 (70)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (80)
    Detroit Become Human (79)
    A Way Out (78)
    Biomutant (78)
    Travis Strikes Again (70)
    State of Decay 2 (79)
    Left Alive (Delay)
    Metro Exodus (85)
    Mega Man 11 (77)
    Far Cry 5 (85)
    Dreams (89)
    Anthem (76)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (80)
    Days Gone (80)
    Shenmue 3 (78)
    Yakuza 6 (76)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delay)



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (91)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (74)
    Monster Hunter World (84)
    Dragon Ball FighterZ (77)
    Spider-Man (84)
    God of War (90)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delay)
    Soul Calibur 6 (51)
    Vampyr (64)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (71`)
    Metal Gear Survive (70)
    Sea of Thieves (81)
    Crackdown 3 (67)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (76)
    Detroit Become Human (80)
    A Way Out (88)
    Biomutant (Delay)
    Travis Strikes Again (Delay)
    State of Decay 2 (79)
    Left Alive (Delay)
    Metro Exodus (76)
    Mega Man 11 (82)
    Far Cry 5 (80)
    Dreams (77)
    Anthem (80)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (86)
    Days Gone (81)
    Shenmue 3 (Delay)
    Yakuza 6 (79)
    Bayonetta 3 (delay)



  • Last of Us Part 2 - 94
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 93
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 84
    Monster Hunter World - 83
    Dragonball FighterZ - 87
    Spider-Man - 89
    God of War - 90
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - Delay
    Soul Calibur 6 - 82
    Vampyr - 70
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 74
    Metal Gear Survive - 71
    Sea of Thieves - 92
    Crackdown 3 - Cancelled
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 86
    Detroit Become Human - 72
    A Way Out - 90
    Biomutant - 74
    Travis Strikes Again - 83
    State of Decay 2 - 81
    Left Alive - 72
    Metro Exodus - 77
    Mega Man 11 - 88
    Far Cry 5 - 84
    Dreams - 78
    Anthem - 86
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 80
    Days Gone - 85
    Shenmue 3 - 81
    Yakuza 6 - 84
    Bayonetta 3 - Delay



  • Didn't do this last year, so I'll hop in with this one.

    Last of Us Part 2 - Delay
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 96
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 82
    Monster Hunter World - 86
    Dragonball FighterZ - 80
    Spider-Man - 92
    God of War - 88
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - Delay
    Soul Calibur 6 - 84
    Vampyr - 78
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 77
    Metal Gear Survive - 70
    Sea of Thieves - 82
    Crackdown 3 - Delay... again. Kidding! 78
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 81
    Detroit Become Human - 85
    A Way Out - 93
    Biomutant - 88
    Travis Strikes Again - 81
    State of Decay 2 - 76
    Left Alive - 79
    Metro Exodus - 90
    Mega Man 11 - 82
    Far Cry 5 - 86
    Dreams - 88
    Anthem - Delay
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 85
    Days Gone - 83
    Shenmue 3 - Delay
    Yakuza 6 - 84
    Bayonetta 3 - 94



  • said in Guess the Metacritic (2018):

    Last of Us Part 2 (delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (94)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (85)
    Monster Hunter World (85)
    Dragonball FighterZ (82)
    Spider-Man (84)
    God of War (82)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (80)
    Soul Calibur 6 (78)
    Vampyr (83)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (88)
    Metal Gear Survive (76)
    Sea of Thieves (83)
    Crackdown 3 (69 NIIICE)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (80)
    Detroit Become Human (81)
    A Way Out (78)
    Biomutant (delay)
    Travis Strikes Again (81)
    State of Decay 2 (75)
    Left Alive (77)
    Metro Exodus (90)
    Mega Man 11 (delay)
    Far Cry 5 (90)
    Dreams (94)
    Anthem (76)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (87)
    Days Gone (84)
    Shenmue 3 (83)
    Yakuza 6 (84)
    Bayonetta 3 (delay)



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (92)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (86)
    Monster Hunter World (80)
    Dragonball FighterZ (76)
    Spider-Man (88)
    God of War (85)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delay)
    Soul Calibur 6 (81)
    Vampyr (72)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (74)
    Metal Gear Survive (73)
    Sea of Thieves (76)
    Crackdown 3 (78)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (84)
    Detroit Become Human (79)
    A Way Out (83)
    Biomutant (Delay)
    Travis Strikes Again (Delay)
    State of Decay 2 (68)
    Left Alive (Delay)
    Metro Exodus (87)
    Mega Man 11 (80)
    Far Cry 5 (82)
    Dreams (Delay)
    Anthem (Delay)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (80)
    Days Gone (83)
    Shenmue 3 (Delay)
    Yakuza 6 (85)
    Bayonetta 3 (91)

    Last time I predicted no delays, this time I think I predicted too many.



  • Last of Us Part 2 delayed
    Red Dead Redemption 2 94
    Ni no Kuni 2 83
    Monster Hunter World 87
    Dragonball FighterZ 90
    Spider-Man 85
    God of War 87
    Kingdom Hearts 3 delayed
    Soul Calibur 6 80
    Vampyr 75
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night 80
    Metal Gear Survive 70
    Sea of Thieves 82
    Crackdown 3 75
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 84
    Detroit Become Human 81
    A Way Out 82
    Biomutant 86
    Travis Strikes Again 78
    State of Decay 2 73
    Left Alive 70
    Metro Exodus 87
    Mega Man 11 80
    Far Cry 5 82
    Dreams 80
    Anthem 78
    Kingdom Come Deliverance 70
    Days Gone 80
    Shenmue 3 80
    Yakuza 6 91
    Bayonetta 3 delayed



  • Last of Us Part 2 - Delay
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 93
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 89
    Monster Hunter World - 88
    Dragonball FighterZ - 91
    Spider-Man - 90
    God of War - 89
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - 85
    Soul Calibur 6 - 85
    Vampyr - 82
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 79
    Metal Gear Survive - 75
    Sea of Thieves - 80
    Crackdown 3 - 78
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 86
    Detroit Become Human - 87
    A Way Out - 79
    Biomutant - 83
    Travis Strikes Again - delay
    State of Decay 2 - 85
    Left Alive - delay
    Metro Exodus - 88
    Mega Man 11 - 82
    Far Cry 5 - 86
    Dreams - 82
    Anthem - 80
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 77
    Days Gone - 85
    Shenmue 3 - delay
    Yakuza 6 - 84
    Bayonetta 3 - 91



  • I should probably take part in the game I posted.

    Last of Us Part 2 DELAY
    Red Dead Redemption 2 93
    Ni no Kuni 2 85
    Monster Hunter World 90
    Dragonball FighterZ 91
    Spider-Man 88
    God of War 86
    Kingdom Hearts 3 85
    Soul Calibur 6 80
    Vampyr 75
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night 70
    Metal Gear Survive 70
    Sea of Thieves 88
    Crackdown 3 65
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 83
    Detroit Become Human 80
    A Way Out 78
    Biomutant 82
    Travis Strikes Again DELAY
    State of Decay 2 75
    Left Alive DELAY
    Metro Exodus 76
    Mega Man 11 86
    Far Cry 5 74
    Dreams DELAY
    Anthem DELAY
    Kingdom Come Deliverance 77
    Days Gone 76
    Shenmue 3 DELAY
    Yakuza 6 89
    Bayonetta 3 86

    I want to believe in Shenmue, but it needs more time. Sorry Huber...
    Almost gave a cancellation to Crackdown 3, but Xbox needs that game, whether it ends up being bad or not.



  • Gonna do my thing again, but I'm going to edge higher this year. Average of 80 per title, but with delays...

    Biomutant
    Travis Strikes Again
    Metro
    Shenmue



  • Last of Us Part 2 - 2019
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 96
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 90
    Monster Hunter World - 85
    Dragonball FighterZ - 87
    Spider-Man - 89
    God of War - 92
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - 2019
    Soul Calibur 6 - 80
    Vampyr - 75
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 80
    Metal Gear Survive - 65
    Sea of Thieves - 75
    Crackdown 3 - 2019
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 2019
    Detroit Become Human - 85
    A Way Out - 87
    Biomutant - 2019
    Travis Strikes Again - 82
    State of Decay 2 - 80
    Left Alive - 2019
    Metro Exodus - 86
    Mega Man 11 - 78
    Far Cry 5 - 80
    Dreams - 90
    Anthem - 2019
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 70
    Days Gone - 86
    Shenmue 3 - 2019
    Yakuza 6 - 86
    Bayonetta 3 - 2019



  • Last of Us Part 2 (delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (92)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (87)
    Monster Hunter World (83)
    Dragonball FighterZ (86)
    Spider-Man (89)
    God of War (84)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (93)
    Soul Calibur 6 (78)
    Vampyr (77)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (74)
    Metal Gear Survive (65)
    Sea of Thieves (81)
    Crackdown 3 (70)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (83)
    Detroit Become Human (89)
    A Way Out (85)
    Biomutant (76)
    Travis Strikes Again (78)
    State of Decay 2 (81)
    Left Alive (74)
    Metro Exodus (89)
    Mega Man 11 (87)
    Far Cry 5 (84)
    Dreams (80)
    Anthem (delay)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (82)
    Days Gone (76)
    Shenmue 3 (delay)
    Yakuza 6 (87)
    Bayonetta 3 (88)



  • I like how only @DeweyDTruman believes in Last of Us Part 2. Could be a big win if that does release this year.



  • @Inustar I mean they've said it is long ways off haven't they?, I honestly don't think there's any reason to think it is 2018



  • @Inustar Would be funny if it does come out this year but gets a 75 metacritic and he still scores 0 points! :D



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delayed)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (94)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (84)
    Monster Hunter World (91)
    Dragonball FighterZ (88)
    Spider-Man (81)
    God of War (90)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delayed)
    Soul Calibur 6 (84)
    Vampyr (79)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (77)
    Metal Gear Survive (71)
    Sea of Thieves (82)
    Crackdown 3 (80)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (84)
    Detroit Become Human (77)
    A Way Out (86)
    Biomutant (Delayed)
    Travis Strikes Again (Delayed)
    State of Decay 2 (81)
    Left Alive (79)
    Metro Exodus (88)
    Mega Man 11(83)
    Far Cry 5 (79)
    Dreams (84)
    Anthem (78)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (80)
    Days Gone (81)
    Shenmue 3 (Delayed)
    Yakuza 6 (88)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delayed)

    In betting big on delays this year.



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delayed)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (96)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (86)
    Monster Hunter World (87)
    Dragonball FighterZ (84)
    Spider-Man (89)
    God of War (92)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delayed)
    Soul Calibur 6 (82)
    Vampyr (79)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (85)
    Metal Gear Survive (78)
    Sea of Thieves (79)
    Crackdown 3 (78)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (83)
    Detroit Become Human (77)
    A Way Out (86)
    Biomutant (75)
    Travis Strikes Again (76)
    State of Decay 2 (80)
    Left Alive (Delayed)
    Metro Exodus (82)
    Mega Man 11 (86)
    Far Cry 5 (80)
    Dreams (83)
    Anthem (Delayed)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (73)
    Days Gone (87)
    Shenmue 3 (Delayed)
    Yakuza 6 (81)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delayed)



  • I did pretty weak the last time, let's try again.

    Last of Us Part 2 - DELAYED
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 93
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 89
    Monster Hunter World - 85
    Dragonball FighterZ - 84
    Spider-Man - 86
    God of War - 90
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - 83
    Soul Calibur 6 - 82
    Vampyr - 77
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 75
    Metal Gear Survive - 73
    Sea of Thieves - 81
    Crackdown 3 - CANCELLED
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 86
    Detroit Become Human - 79
    A Way Out - 77
    Biomutant - 76
    Travis Strikes Again - 69
    State of Decay 2 - 74
    Left Alive - 75
    Metro Exodus - 84
    Mega Man 11 - 81
    Far Cry 5 - 83
    Dreams - 82
    Anthem - 80
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 81
    Days Gone - 84
    Shenmue 3 - DELAYED
    Yakuza 6 - 86
    Bayonetta 3 - DELAYED