Guess the Metacritic (2018)



  • @Inustar I mean they've said it is long ways off haven't they?, I honestly don't think there's any reason to think it is 2018



  • @Inustar Would be funny if it does come out this year but gets a 75 metacritic and he still scores 0 points! :D



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delayed)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (94)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (84)
    Monster Hunter World (91)
    Dragonball FighterZ (88)
    Spider-Man (81)
    God of War (90)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delayed)
    Soul Calibur 6 (84)
    Vampyr (79)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (77)
    Metal Gear Survive (71)
    Sea of Thieves (82)
    Crackdown 3 (80)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (84)
    Detroit Become Human (77)
    A Way Out (86)
    Biomutant (Delayed)
    Travis Strikes Again (Delayed)
    State of Decay 2 (81)
    Left Alive (79)
    Metro Exodus (88)
    Mega Man 11(83)
    Far Cry 5 (79)
    Dreams (84)
    Anthem (78)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (80)
    Days Gone (81)
    Shenmue 3 (Delayed)
    Yakuza 6 (88)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delayed)

    In betting big on delays this year.



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delayed)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (96)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (86)
    Monster Hunter World (87)
    Dragonball FighterZ (84)
    Spider-Man (89)
    God of War (92)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delayed)
    Soul Calibur 6 (82)
    Vampyr (79)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (85)
    Metal Gear Survive (78)
    Sea of Thieves (79)
    Crackdown 3 (78)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (83)
    Detroit Become Human (77)
    A Way Out (86)
    Biomutant (75)
    Travis Strikes Again (76)
    State of Decay 2 (80)
    Left Alive (Delayed)
    Metro Exodus (82)
    Mega Man 11 (86)
    Far Cry 5 (80)
    Dreams (83)
    Anthem (Delayed)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (73)
    Days Gone (87)
    Shenmue 3 (Delayed)
    Yakuza 6 (81)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delayed)



  • I did pretty weak the last time, let's try again.

    Last of Us Part 2 - DELAYED
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 93
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 89
    Monster Hunter World - 85
    Dragonball FighterZ - 84
    Spider-Man - 86
    God of War - 90
    Kingdom Hearts 3 - 83
    Soul Calibur 6 - 82
    Vampyr - 77
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 75
    Metal Gear Survive - 73
    Sea of Thieves - 81
    Crackdown 3 - CANCELLED
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 86
    Detroit Become Human - 79
    A Way Out - 77
    Biomutant - 76
    Travis Strikes Again - 69
    State of Decay 2 - 74
    Left Alive - 75
    Metro Exodus - 84
    Mega Man 11 - 81
    Far Cry 5 - 83
    Dreams - 82
    Anthem - 80
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 81
    Days Gone - 84
    Shenmue 3 - DELAYED
    Yakuza 6 - 86
    Bayonetta 3 - DELAYED



  • I know nothing about several of these games so we'll see how I do haha

    Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (96)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (94)
    Monster Hunter World (95)
    Dragonball FighterZ (93)
    Spider-Man (90)
    God of War (93)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (89)
    Soul Calibur 6 (78)
    Vampyr (75)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (81)
    Metal Gear Survive (80)
    Sea of Thieves (79)
    Crackdown 3 (Delay)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (87)
    Detroit Become Human (82)
    A Way Out (80)
    Biomutant (78)
    Travis Strikes Again (75)
    State of Decay 2 (80)
    Left Alive (78)
    Metro Exodus (85)
    Mega Man 11 (78)
    Far Cry 5 (85)
    Dreams (80)
    Anthem (80)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (82)
    Days Gone (85)
    Shenmue 3 (Delay)
    Yakuza 6 (87)
    Bayonetta 3 (Delay)



  • Last of Us Part 2 (delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (95)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (89)
    Monster Hunter World (87)
    Dragonball FighterZ (88)
    Spider-Man (90)
    God of War (93)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (90)
    Soul Calibur 6 (83)
    Vampyr (80)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (82)
    Metal Gear Survive (69)
    Sea of Thieves (85)
    Crackdown 3 (73)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (85)
    Detroit Become Human (86)
    A Way Out (84)
    Biomutant (80)
    Travis Strikes Again (81)
    State of Decay 2 (83)
    Left Alive (delay)
    Metro Exodus (86)
    Mega Man 11 (83)
    Far Cry 5 (84)
    Dreams (85)
    Anthem (83)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (81)
    Days Gone (80)
    Shenmue 3 (78)
    Yakuza 6 (82)
    Bayonetta 3 (delayed)



  • Maybe I'm being too pessimistic, but here's my list

    Last of Us Part 2 (delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 95
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 88
    Monster Hunter World - 92
    Dragonball FighterZ - 84
    Spider-Man - 77
    God of War - 82
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (delay)
    Soul Calibur 6 - 76
    Vampyr - 72
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 68
    Metal Gear Survive - 62
    Sea of Thieves - 77
    Crackdown 3 (delay)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 84
    Detroit Become Human - 80
    A Way Out - 81
    Biomutant - 80
    Travis Strikes Again (delay)
    State of Decay 2 - 74
    Left Alive (delay)
    Metro Exodus - 77
    Mega Man 11 - 72
    Far Cry 5 - 76
    Dreams - 90
    Anthem (delay)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 73
    Days Gone - 89
    Shenmue 3 (delay)
    Yakuza 6 - 74
    Bayonetta 3 (delay)



  • Thanks @Inustar you beat me to it! (Results from last year's game is here: https://forums.easyallies.com/topic/2055/guess-the-metacritic-2017/60)

    Last of Us Part 2 (Delay)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (96)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (87)
    Monster Hunter World (87)
    Dragonball FighterZ (84)
    Spider-Man (88)
    God of War (90)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (81)
    Soul Calibur 6 (82)
    Vampyr (78)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (83)
    Metal Gear Survive (71)
    Sea of Thieves (78)
    Crackdown 3 (75)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (81)
    Detroit Become Human (83)
    A Way Out (82)
    Biomutant (80)
    Travis Strikes Again (80)
    State of Decay 2 (83)
    Left Alive (78)
    Metro Exodus (85)
    Mega Man 11 (80)
    Far Cry 5 (81)
    Dreams (86)
    Anthem (Delay)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (82)
    Days Gone (82)
    Shenmue 3 (Delay)
    Yakuza 6 (84)
    Bayonetta 3 (87)



  • Last of Us Part 2 - DELAYED
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (95)
    Ni no Kuni 2 (85)
    Monster Hunter World (83)
    Dragonball FighterZ (89)
    Spider-Man (88)
    God of War (88)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (84)
    Soul Calibur 6 (82)
    Vampyr (79)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (85)
    Metal Gear Survive (77)
    Sea of Thieves (82)
    Crackdown 3 (84)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (82)
    Detroit Become Human (76)
    A Way Out (82)
    Biomutant (82)
    Travis Strikes Again - DELAYED
    State of Decay 2 - (87)
    Left Alive - DELAYED
    Metro Exodus - DELAYED
    Mega Man 11 - (80)
    Far Cry 5 (84)
    Dreams (92)
    Anthem - DELAYED
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - (83)
    Days Gone (86)
    Shenmue 3 - DELAYED
    Yakuza 6 - (82)
    Bayonetta 3 - DELAYED



  • Last of Us Part 2 = Delayed
    Red Dead Redemption 2 = 96
    Ni no Kuni 2 = 87
    Monster Hunter World = 88
    Dragonball FighterZ = 86
    Spider-Man = 89
    God of War = 91
    Kingdom Hearts 3 = Delayed
    Soul Calibur 6 = 80
    Vampyr = 81
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night = 82
    Metal Gear Survive = 66
    Sea of Thieves = 82
    Crackdown 3 = 75
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 = 84
    Detroit Become Human = 87
    A Way Out = 83
    Biomutant = 80
    Travis Strikes Again = 81
    State of Decay 2 = 80
    Left Alive = Delayed
    Metro Exodus = 84
    Mega Man 11= 79
    Far Cry 5 = 77
    Dreams = 84
    Anthem = 81
    Kingdom Come Deliverance = 84
    Days Gone = 82
    Shenmue 3 = Delayed
    Yakuza 6 = 82
    Bayonetta 3 = 87



  • Last of Us Part 2 Delay
    Red Dead Redemption 2 96
    Ni no Kuni 2 85
    Monster Hunter World 86
    Dragonball FighterZ 85
    Spider-Man 91
    God of War 92
    Kingdom Hearts 3 84
    Soul Calibur 6 Delay
    Vampyr 78
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night 80
    Metal Gear Survive 70
    Sea of Thieves 81
    Crackdown 3 78
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 82
    Detroit Become Human 81
    A Way Out 86
    Biomutant 79
    Travis Strikes Again 82
    State of Decay 2 81
    Left Alive 83
    Metro Exodus 77
    Mega Man 11 80
    Far Cry 5 75
    Dreams 89
    Anthem Delay
    Kingdom Come Deliverance 79
    Days Gone 82
    Shenmue 3 Delay
    Yakuza 6 83
    Bayonetta 3 93



  • Last of Us Part 2- delayed
    Red Dead Redemption 2- 98
    Ni no Kuni 2- 87
    Monster Hunter World- 86
    Dragonball FighterZ- 84
    Spider-Man- 85
    God of War- 84
    Kingdom Hearts 3- delayed
    Soul Calibur 6- 72
    Vampyr- 74
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night- 79
    Metal Gear Survive-78
    Sea of Thieves- 80
    Crackdown 3- 82
    Valkyria Chronicles 4- 84
    Detroit Become Human- 80
    A Way Out- 83
    Biomutant- delayed
    Travis Strikes Again- 81
    State of Decay 2- no idea, 80
    Left Alive- delayed
    Metro Exodus- 82
    Mega Man 11- 77
    Far Cry 5- 82
    Dreams- 81
    Anthem- delayed
    Kingdom Come Deliverance- 84
    Days Gone- 78
    Shenmue 3- 82
    Yakuza 6- 81
    Bayonetta 3- 89

    CALLING IT RIGHT NOW.
    RDR2 ONE OF THE GREATS.



  • Last of Us Part 2 (Delayed) - (Delayed) = 5 pts
    Red Dead Redemption 2 (96) - (97) = 9 pts
    Ni no Kuni 2 (86) - (84) = 8 pts
    Monster Hunter World (87) - (90) = 7 pts
    Dragonball FighterZ (84) - (87) = 7 pts
    Spider-Man (89) - (87) = 8 pts
    God of War (92) - (94) = 8 pts
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (Delayed) - (Delayed)= 5 pts
    Soul Calibur 6 (82) - (84) = 8 pts
    Vampyr (79) - (70) = 1 pts
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night (85) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Metal Gear Survive (78) - (60) = 0 pts
    Sea of Thieves (79) - (69) = 0 pts
    Crackdown 3 (78) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 (83) - (84) = 9 pts
    Detroit Become Human (77) - (78) = 9 pts
    A Way Out (86) - (78) = 2 pts
    Biomutant (75) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Travis Strikes Again (76) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    State of Decay 2 (80) - (66) = 0 pts
    Left Alive (Delayed) - (Delayed) = 5 pts
    Metro Exodus (82) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Mega Man 11 (86) - (82) = 6 pts
    Far Cry 5 (80) - 81 = 9 pts
    Dreams (83) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Anthem (Delayed) - (Delayed) = 5 pts
    Kingdom Come Deliverance (73) - (76) = 7 pts
    Days Gone (87) - (Delayed) = 0 pts
    Shenmue 3 (Delayed)- (Delayed)= 5 pts
    Yakuza 6 (81) - (83) = 8 pts
    Bayonetta 3 (Delayed) - (Delayed) = 5 pts

    Total points: 136 points

    Looks like I'd too much faith in some titles, like I thought for an example that journalists would give MGS: Survive a easy pass just because of the franchise and I believed way too much in State of Decay 2 and Vampyr.



  • I got like 88pts



  • Ended up with 93 points. Dead on the money with SoulCalibur VI and Mega Man 11, greatly overestimated A Way Out and Sea of Thieves, and missed a bunch of delays. I tempted fate and made a joke about Crackdown getting delayed again, how young and naive I was back then.

    Edit: I stopped counting at FarCry 5, accidentally missed the rest of the list, so I actually finished at 112 points. Take that, nerds!



  • Made a master list, hopefully it's easy to read.

    • Last of Us Part 2
      Delayed
    • Red Dead Redemption 2
      97
    • Ni no Kuni 2
      84
    • Monster Hunter World
      90
    • Dragonball FighterZ
      87
    • Spider-Man
      87
    • God of War
      94
    • Kingdom Hearts 3
      Delayed
    • Soul Calibur 6
      84
    • Vampyr
      70
    • Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night
      Delayed
    • Metal Gear Survive
      60
    • Sea of Thieves
      69
    • Crackdown 3
      Delayed
    • Valkyria Chronicles 4
      84
    • Detroit Become Human
      78
    • A Way Out
      78
    • Biomutant
      Delayed
    • Travis Strikes Again
      Delayed
    • State of Decay 2
      66
    • Left Alive
      Delayed
    • Metro Exodus
      Delayed
    • Mega Man 11
      82
    • Far Cry 5
      81
    • Dreams
      Delayed
    • Anthem
      Delayed
    • Kingdom Come Deliverance
      76
    • Days Gone
      Delayed
    • Shenmue 3
      Delayed
    • Yakuza 6
      83
    • Bayonetta 3
      Delayed


  • Got a 90, total. The worst thing about that list? Almost half, 13 of 31, were delayed into 2019 or beyond. Oof.

    As a side note, last year the list of 22 games posted had an average meta score of 64% and 5 delays. Since the list was posted, all but two delays were published: Scalebound and Crackdown 3.

    For 2018, a total of 31 games were posted, with an average meta score of 87% and 13 delays.



  • Last of Us Part 2 (delay) - correct (+5)
    Red Dead Redemption 2 - 95 --> 97 (+8)
    Ni no Kuni 2 - 88 -->84 (+6)
    Monster Hunter World - 92 --> 90 (+8)
    Dragonball FighterZ - 84 --> 87 (+7)
    Spider-Man - 77 -->87 (0)
    God of War - 82 --> 94 (l0l)
    Kingdom Hearts 3 (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    Soul Calibur 6 - 76 --> 84 (+2)
    Vampyr - 72 -->70 (+8)
    Bloodstained: Ritual of the Night - 68 --> Delay (0)
    Metal Gear Survive - 62 --> 60 (+8)
    Sea of Thieves - 77 --> 69 (+2)
    Crackdown 3 (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    Valkyria Chronicles 4 - 84 --> BOOM (+12)
    Detroit Become Human - 80 --> 78 (+8)
    A Way Out - 81 --> 78 (+7)
    Biomutant - 80 --> Delayed (0)
    Travis Strikes Again (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    State of Decay 2 - 74 --> 66 (+2)
    Left Alive (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    Metro Exodus - 77 --> Delay (+5)
    Mega Man 11 - 72 --> 82 (0)
    Far Cry 5 - 76 --> 81 (+5)
    Dreams - 90 --> Delayed (0)
    Anthem (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    Kingdom Come Deliverance - 73 --> 76 (+7)
    Days Gone - 89 --> Delayed (0)
    Shenmue 3 (delay) --> Correct (+5)
    Yakuza 6 - 74 --> 83 (+1)
    Bayonetta 3 (delay) --> Correct (+5)

    Total: 136
    Did I do that math right? Seems high.



  • @naltmank 131 (current champ too!), you accidentally gave yourself points with Metro.