The EZA Community Top 25 Best of 2018!
Axel last edited by
@brannox Their original pitch was "Dungeons without Dragons", so they've always tried to make this time period and historical accuracy one of their big selling points. Whether that worked out or not is another question :)
I backed the game on Kickstarter so got it day one but still haven't played it, I waited for the dust to settle and patches to arrive as it had tons of bugs at launch. It's currently the top priority in my backlog but with Resident Evil 2 coming out today and the crazy February and March lineups on the way, I don't know when I'll ever get to it.
Brannox last edited by Brannox
@axel Dungeons without Dragons eh?..... Well, I prefer my Dungeons WITH Dragons, so I guess that's another knock against it for me. X-)
But still, I applaud the effort to stick with the setting.
bam541 last edited by bam541
I'm going to finish this game one day (can't rate it higher since i haven't finish it), it'll never leave my PS4 hard drive until said day. I already said my praises for this wonderful game before, so yeah. It's the ultimate (and jankiest) immersive RPG game.
iboshow last edited by
I was excited for this game until I saw the combat
ffff0 last edited by
First personal GotY at #21. No doubt: 2018 had very diverse lineup of great games.
Hazz3r last edited by
High Budget Eurojank is just wonderful on so many levels. There’s brilliance among the bugs; with the combat that you, the player, get better at; the great role playing elements, and the strong commitment to immersive sim. It reminds me a lot of The Witcher 1 in a way. I hope we see Kingdom Come again.
Sentinel Beach last edited by Sentinel Beach
I really like that games like KCD exist. It would propably be a bit too overwhelming for me, but I've read good things about it and seen other people nominate it for their GOTY on another forum I use.
That said, it's starting to seem that Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales didn't make it. I don't see it in the top20, as I've been pretty much the only one talking about it here with @ffff0. I hope that Witcher fans and gwent enthusiasts would play it. The story and dialogue quality is just as good as in W3 and the card battles are exciting as hell. I would've hoped that the Allies had nominated it for the Best Strategy Game or the Best Puzzle game, but none of them had played it at that point, sadly. I gave it 2 points, it was my #4.
ffff0 last edited by
@sentinel-beach My experience with Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales was like this:
- I enjoy The Witcher 3 and Gwent in it.
- I hear that they make standalone Gwent with single player campaign and want to play it.
- I receive an email about Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales and watch the trailer. I don't understand what is this game and decide to ignore it.
- I hear some positive things about this game, but keep ignoring it.
- After hearing another positive feedback I decide to play it.
- I can't stop playing it because I enjoy every aspect of this game.
I feel that many gamers have similar path with Thronebreaker: The Witcher Tales, but they stopped at step 3 or 4.
iboshow last edited by
@ffff0 This is why Shadow drops means failure most of the time.
I havent played Kingdom Come myself. I skipped out on release when I saw all the bugs and graphical issues (I know its better now). But I got a couple friends playing it and they constantly rave about it, like its the best invention since preslized bread. It kinda puts me off it even more, in a funny way.
El Shmiablo last edited by
I'm just posting to say that this is such a jolly way to reveal the list. The microdiscussions about each game between every reveal just make me happy.
Looking forward to discussing my picks in a few days because I'm a basic ass bitch who picked the obvious shit.
DIPSET last edited by
I want to try this game but I don't have hours and hours to sink into a big boy cRPG. I do admire that they went for medieval without going medieval fantasy which I find can get boring easily if it doesn't have some sort of hook like, say, Demon's Souls.
Like I really truly do appreciate the historical fiction angle. Some of my favourite novels are well researched historical fiction where you can get an interesting story AND learn a lot too. I think video games could do this more often, but "historical" storytelling in games usually comes off as a fantastical mess like Nioh.
El Shmiablo last edited by
@dipset I think I remember hearing that the new Total War game based on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms will have an option for generals to have superpowers like the legends, or be more historically accurate and just fight normally.
Faaip last edited by Faaip
Nice, I'm glad Kingdom Come got some recognition. Its super ambitious and I think it did a lot of things really well. Its open world for example is one of the most beautiful and real feeling I've seen in a game like that.. it was a joy to explore and travel through it. I also love the armor and outfit customization and the combat is pretty cool once you get the hang of it. I appreciate that they really strove to represent the time period as authentically as possible. I think other similar open world rpgs could learn a lot from this game (looking at you elder scrolls)
That said it was pretty janky and at times felt like a chore. There was too much good stuff this year so it gets an honorable mention from me
Axel last edited by
#19. Ni no Kuni II: Revenant Kingdom - 11 points
#2: 1 (Sazime)
#4: 1 (SabotageTheTruth)
HM: 5 (A7X458, Tearju Engi, Danjin44, Faaip, Capnbobamous)
Release date: March 23 [US/EU]
Publisher: Bandai Namco Entertainment
Genre: Action role-playing
Platform(s): PlayStation 4, Microsoft Windows
#19. Tetris Effect - 11 points
#2: 1 (DMCMaster)
#4: 1 (Hanabi)
HM: 5 (Inustar, TokyoSlim, El Shmiablo, bam541, AbsoluteUppercut)
Release date: November 9 [US/EU]
Developer: Monstars Inc., Resonair
Publisher: Enhance, Inc.
Platform(s): PlayStation 4
Hanabi last edited by
Tetris Effect is amazing, honestly surprised how few points it got.
Mbun last edited by
If they're just going to phone them in like Ni no Kuni II, then I hope they just stop making those games entirely. Might be my biggest disappointment of 2018. Look at how ambitious the ones before it are, then look back at II and all the problems it has and shortcuts it takes. People would be spitting on this game much more if it didn't carry the Ghibli style.
Tetris Effect on the other hand blew my expectations away. Not only did the story mode keep the visualizers interesting and have a large variety of them, but there was a good handful of great music, and best of all they included like over a dozen other ways to play Tetris within the same game with an incredibly polished shell around it all. I expected it to be the kind of game you beat and move on from, but you really could keep playing this game for years, and even longer if they decided to start releasing DLC and turn it into Tetris as a service.
Capnbobamous last edited by
@mbun Yo if you didn't like Ni No Kuni 2, that's fine, but you can't call it phoned in. It's a very fun, whimsical game that has many neat features and mechanics. The overworld missions are fun, the combat, while not hard, is enjoyable, and building the kingdom is immensely satisfying. This is a game made by passionate developers, and to call it phoned in is an insult to the people who poured themselves into it.
I don't understand all of the complaints against the difficulty as well. Why does the game need to be hard? To me the game is good because it is a stress-free reprieve from life - it doesn't have to be anything more than that. The story, while pretty basic, is interesting enough to keep me invested, and the world itself is just magical. The music is good as well.
Hidz last edited by
From someone who haven't played the first game, I enjoyed my time with Ni No Kuni 2, I loved the kingdom building and the jolly atmosphere.
I'd love to play the first game, I hope we'll see a remaster of it some time in the future!
Brannox last edited by
Well a tie without a clear-cut tiebreaker! I find it pretty funny how both games got the same number of votes at each level.
On Ni No Kuni II, heading into the year, I felt this was one of the higher anticipated games for the first quarter from a consensus standpoint in light of how well the first game was received. But from what I gather, it was either really liked or MAJORLY missed the mark. I remember for PSX 2015 it was probably the big announcement in the second half of that conference (Remember, that show opened with Uncharted 4's unveiling of dialogue and Sam followed immediately by the second Final Fantasy VII: Remake trailer). While a solid take on JRPGs, there's a lot of... for lack of a better way to explain it... weird that turns me off regarding this franchise. I'm happy it was received relatively well, and it outshined more big name games in reception (Sea of Thieves and Far Cry 5 immediately jump to mind).
As for Tetris Effect, I am FASCINATED with this game. The fusion of the classic puzzler and the sensory explosion coming from the creator of Rez make this look so cool. I, however, did not play this because I want to play the best experience possible, and this just DEMANDS itself to be played in PSVR. I don't own the hardware, but this (among other 2018 titles I have a feeling we'll see later) really made VR appealing to me. So, like needing to purchase quality headphones to play Hellblade, I file this under "Games I want to play but don't have the cash/setup for my finicky standards."
But I do agree 19th feels a tad low for it. Goes to show just how strong 2018 was.