The EZA Community Top 20 Best of 2009!

  • @axel It's ok, this helps extend the shorter list a bit :D

  • Banned

    Before Axel attempts to fix his colossal fuckup, I just want to say that New Super Mario is a completely soulless cash-in on the Mario franchise and exemplifies some of the very worst of modern Nintendo next to Pokemon and the various other stupid decisions they make.

  • I was a high schooler in 2009, so technically a kid, and I had no desire to play this new Super Mario Bros. I don't know who they were appealing to tbh. The aesthetic was still Mario, but oddly glossy, the animations were kinda weird. My little brother (probably 8 years old in 2009) definitely liked playing LittleBigPlanet and LEGO Batman / Star Wars around that time, but he didn't even bat an eye at this era of Mario. So again, IDK who Nintendo was catering to with this type of game.

  • Banned

    @dipset I think they were pandering to the crowd of boomers who unironically say shit like "Oh man, remember when we used to play the Marios on our original Nintendo Playstation? Those were the days.".

    It is literally the blandest, most unoffensive, uncreative trash you could possibly think of. Nothing about it sparks the imagination. It is completely void of soul.

  • @el-shmiablo So you’re saying is it was perfect for the millions of adults that had bought it for Wii Sports and Mario Olympics?

  • I feel the same about New Super Mario Bros. Wii. I think it's the only 2D Mario I've never played, and I have absolutely no desire to do so. It really strikes me as having no personality, no "theme", indeed no soul.

    I'm sure it's still extremely competent as a platformer, but it just feels... skippable.

  • Go go Cursed Mountain!

    Mario on Wii is great though. Not sure why that gets a hard time when stuff like Mega Man 9 and 10 gets praised. Nothing wrong with falling back on a tried and tested formula, especially one so highly rated.

  • Forza Motorsport 3

    #20. Forza Motorsport 3 - 5 points


    #1: 1 (Phbz)
    #2: 0
    #3: 0
    #4: 0
    HM: 0


    Release date: October 23 [EU], October 27 [US]
    Developer: Turn 10 Studios
    Publisher: Microsoft
    Genre: Racing
    Platform(s): Xbox 360


    GT Review

  • Someone loved it at least lol.

  • Forza 3 was a personal obsession. Many many hours spent just improving lap times and getting to top 3%-1%. We were just talking on another thread about how goty contenders tend to ignore genres like racing, and here we have a game with 92 on Metacritic that got ignored once the gotys came. Trully phenomenal game, and my 2009 personal goty pick. Even better that thanks to me it will feature in our top 20. :D

  • I didn't own a 360 so I never really tapped into Forza until Forza Motorsport 7 and Forza Horizon 4. I think those games are solid, but I expect the WOW-Factor with those games came around this time because they don't really feel too impactful these days. F7 is kinda meh, but I've heard Forza 3 is a classic.

  • I've never gravitated towards the Forza series as I got my sim fix early enough with Gran Turismo years prior, and I'm set for life with the genre. Though, in Forza 3's case, I actually have the disc because it's a part of a bundle with Halo 3: ODST and when I purchased ODST, it never told me Forza would be bundled with it.

    This means Forza Motorsport 3 is the only game in my entire life I unknowingly purchased, currently own, and have/will never play.

  • GameTrailers review of Forza 3 (made me feel nostalgic)
    Youtube Video

  • Banned

    Forza really could have been great, but the near annual releases hindered the series more than it helped. Now it's stagnated and fallen behind Gran Turismo again. Those earlier entries really gave GT a run for their money though.

    Forza Horizon is in a while but her category though. Sony doesn't have anything that comes close to that in terms of arcade racers. Shame they killed off Motorstorm, since I think that could have been their Horizon with the right direction.

  • Forza Motorsport 3 was where the franchise really started to become the grandaddy of sim racers.

  • Banned

    @jdincinerator Forza is not a sim my dude.

  • Forza Motorsport 3 was great. Spent a lot of time on it with my friends. The Decal Designer was incredibly powerful. I remember watching a video interviewing the developers and they said they had thought that people had hacked the game and were uploading photoshops and stuff.

  • @el-shmiablo Will simcade do?

  • @jdincinerator said in The EZA Community Top 20 Best of 2009!:

    Forza Motorsport 3 was where the franchise really started to become the grandaddy of sim racers.

    Gotta disagree with that statement. I don’t think any one single Forza game can beat any one Gran Turismo game. Even the physics and overall feel of GT6 is better than Forza 6 imo and that was PS3 vs Xbox One. Like I’ll take GT4 > ANY Forza and GT Sport > Forza 7.

  • @dipset Indeed, I thought GT6 was superior to FM5 when they both released in 2013 but I do find that GT generally seems more antiquated than FORZA, although circuit racing is getting very boring now, especially when Forza has the Horizon series.