The EZA Community Top 25 of 2008!
DIPSET last edited by DIPSET
I was camping last week so playing catch up here.
I really liked what I've played of this game in the PS4 Remaster but never finished it. No fault of the game, but I just didn't want to dig too deep at the time. I have a hard time taking "anime war" as serious as the game presents itself, but I feel it's earnestness and the gameplay system speaks for itself.
One of my all time favourite games imo.
Personal anecdote here, but I spent so much of my free time in 2006-2007 just consuming any and all videos about PS3 and next gen. I watched the LBP GDC 2007 demo with the skateboard like 400 times. My 11 year old mind was blown.
(the skateboard demo starts @ 6:19)
TBH, I've never been this wow'd by a presentation in my entire life. I don't think LBP gets enough credit for being a solid game on top of the prototype for the expectation of personal expression in any online game nowadays.
Also, soundtrack is very underrated and blended perfectly into the MM pre-made levels. I personally would always play bomb survival levels with my buddies in 4 player split screen.
A few songs that I still have stuck in my head all these years later:
This game blew me away when I first played it and it's smaller approachable size made it ripe for replays and time trials. DICE are technical wizards and the fact they got a first person parkour game to run and look so smooth still blows me away. The game was built on an extremely early version of Unreal 3 and was in development while Gears 1 still was so DICE kinda took an unfinished tool to the finish line here.
I love the game design in this game. The first level just exists to give you a sense of momentum and keeping speed. As the game goes on it throws a few puzzles at you. A few dodge and chase sections. Then later tells you to mix them all together.
You can read about the making of Mirror's Edge in this little known feature article here:
What's funny is that the people they interview about creating Mirror's Edge don't really even like the game. It apparently was greenlit by EA to be an ambitious project but slowly turned into something a lot less ambitious as the beancounters started seeing Uncharted and Gears 2 sell copies.
There were decisions made that were just questionable. Me and the level designer would sit there and get a level looking really good, and the next day you’d come in and there’d be snipers everywhere.
Mirror’s Edge wasn’t really my cup of tea when it came out. I sat down and played it on PS3 for about an hour and that was it, I gave up. Didn’t like it.
I think he's maybe too close to the game to truly appreciate it, but I think it's fantastic. The sewer level is one of my all time favourite levels.
I love Persona 4 but I don't like the hardcore JRPG mechanics of the original PS2 game. I played P4 in 2015 on the PSN downloads and I hated how devastating dying to a boss in the dungeon was. I don't like having to use items to return to the dungeon hub to save before continuing onwards.
P4:G is just way more streamlined and casual for my tastes. I'm just not that hardcore. Great game, but it wasn't a 2008 game for me.
Never played it. I didn't like Gears 1 so why play Gears 2? Gears 1 is on Game Pass so maybe I'll give it another shake but I didn't like bullet sponges and the constant covering and shooting. That was the whole game to me without much deviation so I just got bored.
I'll write about this when I get more time.
3.WII MUSIC=26 Points of embarrassment
#1:5 (Men who embarrassed themselves at E3 2008)
#2: 9 (The maximum age of the people this game is intended for)
#3:7 (Number of classic videogame compositions that were butchered)
#4: 5 (The age of kids who will benefit most from Wii Music's gameplay)
#HM:0 (For there is no honour in acting like a 5 year-old who gnaws on tambourines)
Release Date: October 20th 2008 (NA), November 13th 2008 (AU), November 14th 2008 (EU)
Developer: Nintendo EAD Group No. 2
JDINCINERATOR last edited by JDINCINERATOR
This post is deleted!
Phbz last edited by
Wtf just happened? Is this correct? 🤣
Crepe last edited by
LMFAO. What a great troll
DIPSET last edited by
Too good haha!
I never knew Wii Music would live in like this in the minds of its victims.
#3.DEAD SPACE=26 Points
#1:3 (El Shmiablo, Axel, Paulmci27)
#4:1 (Sentinel Beach)
HM:2 (Kindiman, Nimbat1003)
Release Date: October 13th 2008 (NA), October 20th 2008 (PC release date), October 23rd 2008 (AU), October 24th 2008 (EU)
Developer: EA Redwood Shores
Genre: Survival horror
Platform: PS3, Xbox 360, PC
Yes it's the real number 3 this time no tomfoolery here. Dead Space was a pretty big deal in 2008. I remember when I played it and I wasn't sure how to play horror games such as it back then. I used to rent out games and play them until I had 10% trophy completion then I'd review them. Obviously I was silly back then, but when it came to Dead Space I only reached 5% trophy completion and gave up. Now fast-forward all these thirteen-years later and considering I've revisited Dead Space a few times since 2008-and it's a cracking horror game. I didn't put it in my top 8 because there were just too many games that I couldn't deny but Dead Space would be in a top 10 possibly or at least top 15 for me. Necromorphs are absolutely sickening in how demented they're shaped and formed and the sounds they make are sure to make you sweat with intensity. I don't know what to say about Isaac Clarke, he's pretty much a guy with an electric-light emitted upturned bin on his head who doesn't speak. I mean Isaac does groan in pain but that's probably due to the fact that he makes for appetizing necromorph bait.
Brannox last edited by
As I've stated multiple times, I'm no fan of horror and as such, I've steered clear of it in all its forms for many years until the full playthrough of Resident Evil VII. And because of that, plus some other factors, Dead Space is now my leading candidate of a full playthrough I would like to see an Ally do. And after the years of calling for a remaster (or a return of any kind really) for the franchise from many finally being heard by EA, I think the wait won't be too much longer.
While the third entry has a terrible reputation, I would like to see both this and its sequel, but until then, I'll stay content to just hang back and wait. Yes, I DO know the twist and how the first letter of every chapter spells it out, but without context, I'm intrigued to experience that as intended. Don't get me wrong: I'll forever be irked by EA shutting down Visceral for a variety of reasons, and I'm stoked to hear the former lead start up his own new studio to make The Callisto Portocol inspired what they made with Dead Space, but I want to reserve judgment until I see EA doesn't mess this remake up.
El Shmiablo Banned last edited by
I grew up on stuff like Alien and Event Horizon, so the first time I played Dead Space I was absolutely mesmerized by how well the game conveyed a sense of constant dread through it's incredible lighting, unparalleled sound design, and overall atmosphere.
The idea that headshots were in most situations the least ideal method of dispatching enemies made combat feel engaging and unique, since the idea of ripping enemies limb from limb and even using those limbs against them was something I'd never really seen in a game before.
The twist and ending left me completely blown away. Real tennouttaten type stuff. I'm fucking frothing at the mouth for the remake and that PUBG spinoff on the moon by the old devs.
Nimbat1003 last edited by
camon we all know it's gonna be fallout 3 right?... right???
Phbz last edited by
World of Goo wasn't mentioned yet so it must mean it will be in the top 2!
#2.FALLOUT 3=49 Points
#1:4 (Shoulderguy, Kindiman, Nimbat1003, Nikhil Sharma)
#2:6 (ffff0, Sentinel Beach, Crepe, Paulmci27, MiserablePerson, Capnbobamous)
#3:1 (James Davie)
#HM:2 (PHBZ, ED_ZED_EH_INTERN)
Release Date: October 28th 2008 (NA), October 30th 2008 (PAL)
Developer: Bethesda Game Studios
Publisher: Bethesda Softworks
Genre: Action role-playing
Platform: PS3, Xbox 360, Microsoft Windows
And the EZA Community 2008 Game of the Year is.....
#1.GTA IV=49 Points
#1:6 (James Davie, Bam541, PHBZ, Sentinel Beach, DIPSET, VicRattler)
#2:2 (Kindiman, Nikhil Sharma)
#3:2 (Shoulderguy, ffff0)
#HM:3 (Crepe, Nimbat1003, MiserablePerson)
Release Date: 29th April 2008
Developer: Rockstar North
Publisher: Rockstar Games
Platform: PS3, Xbox 360, Microsoft Windows
An extremely tight finale but GTA IV just slips by Fallout 3 as the EZA Community 2008 Game of the Year. It's been a very enjoyable ride getting to this spot and with an extremely competitive final 2 it's been very exciting to curate such a fantastic list. As for what can be said about Fallout 3 and GTA IV? Both are incredible games at the tip top of their respective genres at this time. Fallout 3 had a captivating open-world action RPG experience that actually got me into action RPGs. Back in 2008 I thought all RPGs were turn-based, fantastical and samey and Fallout 3 changed my perception completely. As for GTA IV, it's an impeccable open-world sandbox game that bends towards a gritty realistic tilt but is nonetheless utterly enthralling-putting story and characters first has paid off in heaps. I generally couldn't imagine a better final two games to square off.
Thank you very much to all who voted and made this experience so fantastic. It's my first time curating a top 25 on this wonderful community forum. I have to thank @Axel for giving me the reigns to whip this list up. I know there are improvements that need to be made to my approach curating these lists, so if you have recommendations for any improvements I should make feel free to PM me.
Shoulderguy last edited by Shoulderguy
Wow! It doesn't get much closer than that.
@JDINCINERATOR So Fallout 3 had 13 voters and GTA IV had 14. That was the tie-breaker?
@shoulderguy That and GTA IV had more #1 votes.
DemonPirate last edited by
Kinda bummed Devil May Cry 4 didn't make the list at all :|
I forgot to mention that a recap post is coming where I will list all the games that were voted for but didn't make the top 25.
Brannox last edited by
It's been a bit since I haven't been able to comment on at least one of the games to make a final reveal, but c'est la vie. I have no inclination towards Fallout as a franchise, though I do know 3 is brought up the most as the most beloved entry. And far as GTA, I don't need to keep beating the dead horse as it were.
As is tradition for the end of the countdowns, my full list, plus comments on games that didn't show up starting at the bottom:
GOTY: Gears of War 2
2.) Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
3.) Left 4 Dead
4.) God of War: Chains of Olympus
5.) (HM) Ratchet & Clank: Quest for Booty
6.) (HM) Resistance 2
7.) (HM) Mirror's Edge
8.) (HM) Braid
9.) (DIDN'T MAKE THE CUT) Soulcalibur IV
10.) (DIDN'T MAKE THE CUT) Tom Clancy's Rainbow Six Vegas 2
11.) (DIDN'T MAKE THE CUT) Star Wars: The Force Unleashed
12.) (DIDN'T MAKE THE CUT) Need for Speed: Undercover
13.) (DIDN'T MAKE THE CUT) Secret Agent Clank
Secret Agent Clank is straight up not a fun game, or good by any stretch of the imagination. I remember playing it once, getting to the final boss with some kind of difficulty spike mixed with some BS QTE timing, and after having been soured for most of the game (Plus having a terrible with another game for a future countdown if we keep going), for the first time, this put me in a down mood on the franchise, until I realized this wasn't made by Insomniac.
2008 was a time I think I tried out a variety of genres and really becoming in tune with my tastes. And Need for Speed: Undercover was a casualty of this. I think it had a couple of moments of fun here and there in the moment, but the overall experience is a forgettable one with a stupid story and repetitive gameplay I noticed real quick by the end. This turned me solidly away from arcade-y racers and Need for Speed as a whole.
As I just said about playing different kinds of games, so too does this apply to Rainbow Six Vegas 2. Now, my father also got himself a 360, but before doing so, we used mine together for a brief time before he got his, so he went ahead and got a few games he was interested in, and mostly they were military shooters (So Vegas, GRAW, CoD, etc.). From what I remember, the game is fine, but it's not something I really care for, plus as I've aged, I've become more against these kinds of games, so I have no desire to revisit this bizarre premise of terrorists attacking Las Vegas.
Ratchet & Clank: Quest for Booty is the lone game I voted for that didn't appear, which means I THINK this is the most games I voted for that ultimately appeared on a single countdown. And to the greater point, I'm actually really pleased I feel like I was able to comment more than normal. I'm hoping if we keep the pattern going, 2007 will be where I can speak the most. Anyway, regarding QFB, this is a fun time, because I'm a sucker for the robot pirate theme. This also was the first digital-only game I ever owned. However, it's brevity is probably its biggest flaw: You can 100% this game in about three hours, you're only given a handful of weapons with practically pointless upgrading (each given to you is at Level 3, only able to go to Level 5), and though it serves as a nice connecter between Tools of Destruction and A Crack in Time, it feels like that could've either been much more to do OR be tacked on to the beginning of A Crack in Time. Regardless, it's still fun for what it is and an easy recommendation only because it requires very little investment, both in terms of time and commitment.
To close, my thanks to @JDINCINERATOR for picking up the mantle and keeping these going. For the most part, these countdowns have been consistently the threads that have kept me here (sans discussing Hall of Greats, but that's no longer on a consistent schedule) and I always enjoy them. While it's making me sad it appears like there's less and less participation with each thread/year we visit, I totally get why. Regardless, much appreciation to all who contributed, and I'm looking forward to the next one!