The EZA Community Top 20 Best of 2007!
I can't speak to Eternal Sonata beyond when remembering I first heard about the title and thinking, "...uh....what?" and I've never felt any reason to learn anything about it in the last close-to-15 years.. But as it pertains to our countdown, it feels good that it made it for being a GOTY. Those are the kinds of lone votes I like to see: If it's only going to get a single vote, it should be the best to the voter.
As far as the Countdown itself, it bums me out not enough voters/games were able to establish a top 25, as opposed to the top 20 we're getting. 2007 as a whole is one of (and dependent upon your view, THE) year where so many great games came out. So I have the expectation this is going to be a list where games that don't make it are going to be befuddling heartbreakers.
bam541 last edited by
I heard of this game a couple times while I was looking for PS3 games recommendations. Can't really say much about it other than it looks pretty neat.
E_Zed_Eh_Intern last edited by
Of note, Eternal Sonata has 2-player coop so you can assign different characters to each player. Played through it with my wife years ago and it was great fun.
I remember Electric Playground and GameTrailers covering this game a lot back in the day. I never played it though. I don't even think I was into JRPGs back then. I've heard of many people who swear by it though.
NeoCweeny last edited by
I remember wanting to but this back in the day but never happened and some point forgot about this game existence until now.
Shoulderguy last edited by Shoulderguy
I played the Eternal Sonata demo on Xbox 360 back then and it reminded me of Tales of Vesperia, which is one of my favorite games of 2008. I never played the full release but If it ever gets a rerelease on current-gen, I would check it out.
Shoulderguy last edited by
#19: Assassin's Creed - 6 points
#4: 2 (ffff0, Sentinel Beach)
HM: 2 (brunojoey, Capnbobamous)
Release date: NA: November 13, EU: November 16, AU: November 21
Developer: Ubisoft Montreal
Genre: Action-adventure, stealth
Platform(s): PC, Xbox 360, PlayStation 3
There are 16 games I've played from 2007, and Assassin's Creed I have in 13th place. I can't remember why, way back when, I gave it a shot, but it was one of the first games I played on the 360. I remember thinking going after and assassinating key targets was interesting, but I soon became tired of the world, plus I didn't know about the present day stuff, and I thought at the time it not being advertised was a major turn off to me. I felt absolutely irritated when I would get yanked out of the time period for a restrictive and uninteresting lore dump of being trapped in a bland and (relatively) small area with characters who all disliked each other where all you did was walk around and change the camera angles. If I had known at the time it was a split between two time periods with different characters, I may never would have tried it, and subsequently III, and IV: Black Flag (But hindsight being 20/20, who knows). To this day I contend there is not a SINGLE present day segment that's interesting and all are far outclassed by the various time periods these games are actually marketed around.
But back to the first AC: When I WAS able to hop back into being Altair, the more the game progressed, the less fun I had: Diving off large perches into bales of hay became routine instead of keeping it exciting, certain mission types like eavesdropping or flag collecting exposed the padding the game had, plus the major twist was a personal significant let down. Personally, I did not enjoy my overall time with the original (though, again, assassinations in themselves were by far the clear standout moments), and by the time it concluded where you could get Eagle Vision and see the secret messages as Desmond, I backed out to the Home screen, took it out of the disc drive, and gave it a buddy of mine, and I haven't revisited since, as I don't believe it holds up today, ESPECIALLY with the context of all the other entries the series has.
Looking back at the significant history and presence Assassin's Creed has in gaming at large today, I'm surprised this original was the impetus. To be clear: I feel SEVERAL Assassin's Creed games are better than this one for a variety of reasons, but I still hold a disconnect between how the original did well enough to inspire more creative and captivating ideas/time periods from the series, since I hold a "Meh" at best feeling towards it, both now and when I first played it over a decade ago.
This is just me, and it's clear it made enough of an impression to crack our countdown (and the aforementioned juggernaut it's become), so kudos to it. All of this being said, I have it ahead of three other games because one game (which I don't expect to see on this countdown) just didn't feel right on the platform it was on and the other two (one of which I DO expect to appear) are part of franchises I held/hold dear but were entries I felt were the first "Bad/Awful" games for their brands.
And with Assassin's Creed ONLY being 19th, it has me fascinated to see where the rest of the "1st of the Franchise" games that came out in 2007 will rank, if at all.
I couldn't bring myself to add it to my list, but Assassin's Creed is one of the most ambitious and exciting games I have ever played in my entire life, and I don't think I'll ever play something as ambitious as it was ever again.
This demo from 2007 was on repeat when I was in middle-school:
Assassin's Creed: Full Mission - Commented by Jade Raymond
I'd show my friends this video and say things like "you can go a-n-y-w-h-e-r-e". When I finally played it, it was on my friends shiny new PS3 on his Dad's shiny new HDTV and my brain was shattered by how good it looked and how good the animations are.
The repetitive gameplay didn't matter to me. I felt the vision and I loved the experience. I should be playable on modern systems and it's a travesty it isn't.
JDINCINERATOR last edited by
Assassins Creed was fine for its time and refreshing thanks to its crusades time period and fresh settings like Jerusalem and Damascus. The pure focus on assassinations is great too and is free from the filler and excess that plagued many of its successors. Yet the dryness of the game's characters and that whole Abstergo Industries twist were hugely disappointing. Assassins Creed didn't need the present day aesthetic and could've been far better had it been removed. I know I'm rather too critical about Ubisoft's games-probably because Jim Sterling has been hugely influential to my perspective of them, but even when I played it for the first time in 2007 it was unexceptional.
MiserablePerson last edited by
When I scrubbed through 2007, surprisingly I couldn't put together more than 4 games I'd actually played so I skipped the vote. Just wanted to say I came to Assassin's Creed probably a year or so after launch and knew little about it other than a recommendation from a friend. Was very thrown off by the future setting, but it intrigued me, especially as the game inched closer to the end. I'm still incredibly impressed with what this series started as, which makes me all the more disappointed in what it became. II was a good follow-up, but I skipped on Revelations and Bloodlines, and waited until III came out which killed the franchise for me. While I no longer have much interest in playing them, I still hold the original in very high regard and don't understand when I see it put down in modern lists.
FWIW, I loved the present day parts of Assassin’s Creed. It’s like grinding out a dungeon in a JRPG, beating that boss, then being rewarded with that sweet cutscene at the end.
Plus the info was so cryptic and I loved putting the pieces together when you explore the room and new info was hidden and trying to figure out who was holding me hostage. The sci-fi twist was out of left field and I was here for it.
ffff0 last edited by
I’ve came to Assassin’s Creed late and played 1 and 2 trilogy back to back. A bit hard to me to separate 1 from others, but I’ve liked whole experience enough to get into the series, which I’m thankful for because now it’s one of my favorites. I agree that 1 has too much repetition, but it was a unique experience, so I still liked it.
NeoCweeny last edited by
I was very excited for Assassins Creed before release but it was a huge letdown for me. The missions are so boring and repetitive.
It's still the only game i the series I've played. I do want to give the series another shot one of these days.
Sentinel Beach last edited by
I love this series, and the first AC has kept its magic in my mind in a pretty solid way. It was one of the prettiest games I had seen when it came out and the controls felt super slick. One of those first PS3 games for me so that's part of the experience as well: everything was just so new and spectacular. I loved the cities as well and the tight gameplay loop. Would be interesting to revisit this today.
Bigdude1 last edited by
Just saying my top vote would have been galaxy
Shoulderguy last edited by
#18: Skate - 6 points
#2: 1 (DIPSET)
HM: 2 (JDINCINERATOR, Crepe)
Release date: NA: September 14, PAL: September 28, AU: October 11
Developer: EA Black Box
Publisher: Electronic Arts
Platform(s): Xbox 360, PlayStation 3
DIPSET last edited by DIPSET
I said this in a few posts before but 2007 was a magical time in middle school. Every single day the weather was nice, my friends and I were skateboarding before, during, and after school. We'd skate every single weekend and if it wasn't skating, we were mountain biking.
But if we weren't doing that, we were playing video games. And one of the top 2 video games we played was EA Skate. We'd literally play this game with our helmets on.
Now, this isn't all emotion and nostalgia. Skate was a mind-blowing game at the time. Hell, I think it's innovation is still pretty impressive and it's a shame we didn't have the SSD's back then to immediately reload to a session marker instantly.
The control scheme seems like an obvious point of innovation (which is was), but the open world design is still top notch and it's DNA is all over games like Forza Horizon 5. The process of skating through an open world and hitting any spot in sight, but then that spot suddenly gives you a high score to beat. So then you pause whatever you were doing and spend a deal of time just getting a high score at that spot is really cool. It's design is so accessible because you can have seamless unstructured and structured fun depending on your playstyle. From point A to point B you might do a downhill race, film a video part, hit a spot for a high score, fuck with security guards, or just simply have whatever fun you want.
Very few games by today's standards give you a worthwhile and fun experience from A --> B where fun is found anywhere. I can name exactly two other series: GTA and Forza Horizon. That's it.
Beyond game design, there is just so much love and attention to skateboarding. Sure, you use official brands which is nice, but it's awesome to see photographer Atiba Jefferson in the game working for Thrasher Magazine in context of your avatars come up as a pro. The developers are from Vancouver and they were directly integrated with skate culture and it's beyond obvious. San Vanelona is a mash up of San Fran, Vancouver, and LA and it's evident and works on all levels. Especially the San Fran downhill areas (aka The Res).
Skate 2 is the better game but this was the original. I recently went back to replay it and my only gripe is how slow reloading a session marker is. That is a limitation of the PS3 / 360 and not of the game itself. Things load a lot better in Skate 2 and 3 but they still aren't instant. However, revisiting Skate 1 is worthwhile because of the open world and the overall progression as a skate rat to full sponsorship and getting magazine covers.
I can't describe how cool it was to see my favourite pros all in this intro video. Or seeing them skate around the open world. This game is magical and was a part of a magical time in my life.
I had pretty much gotten out of the phase of wanting to play skating games and any interest surrounding skating as a whole by the time Skate came out, and said interest was only linked into enjoying the X-Games which only lasted a few more years after that. The only skating game I have any memory of is one of the Tony Hawk games way back in the day, so any reference I have to Skate is not in the game itself, but rather how it's reached cult status for a comeback from the fans and how EA has finally relented in greenlighting a new one. I don't think I'll ever revisit skating games, regardless of franchise, because my interest in the entire culture/sport have long been over, so Skate will be one of the franchises I'll keep in the "forever passed by" section of my personal gaming history.
JDINCINERATOR last edited by
Although I didn't get the chance to play SKATE in 2007, booting it up on Game Pass this year and experiencing it for the first time was a real pleasure. I always loved SKATE for its leisurely and undemanding pace and the original SKATE was cool as can be. Yes SKATE 2 and SKATE 3 had far more charisma and depth but SKATE is fantastic, doubly so for a new skateboarding game in 2007 away from the tiring THPS franchise.