Amazing: The Pathless. I think it's a very underrated game. It's quite impressive technically considering an indie studio made it, and despite the gameplay loop being somewhat simple, it managed to insert so much flair and personality to it that it never really got boring. I said before that it's very Fumito Ueda-esque in how the game feels (and also the story and how it's presented), and it's also a great quality of the game.
Meh: Going Under. The overall gameplay is quite disappointing, and unfortunately the very well executed story and characters aren't enough to make me like it more.
Rubbish: Star Wars Squadrons. I just never got the hang of the controls. It never felt good or natural to control the ship, and that's certainly a bad thing for a space shooter game.