If this was a question of my three most anticipated games that were present, then it would be Final Fantasy VII: Remake, DOOM: Eternal, and Ori and the Will of the Wisps. However, I'm interpreting the question as what was the best and worst presented games. That said, I'm disqualifying trailers only. So while CyberPunk's entire presentation was exciting, we're not going to see this week's demo for another two months.

For my third favorite presentation, I liked how Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order was a solid 15 minutes of just showing the game. I'm very intrigued by its combat, and hearing parallels to KOTOR in regards to picking which planets you want to go to and when is highly appealing.
However. @^&# spiders.

Second for me is Watch Dogs Legion. I'm not a Watch Dogs fan, and won't be picking up this game, but I think Ubisoft did a great job showing how you can recruit all the different characters of the world. And yes, Helen was the strongest moment. EASILY Ubisoft's high point of their conference.

Number one, no surprise, Final Fantasy VII: Remake. 20 minutes of a deep dive on combat, characters, environment, story, a dedicated segment to a boss fight... Loved it.

As for the three games I came away irked with, each had their own vastly different reasons why I was immensely bothered.

The number three presentation I couldn't stand was Just Dance. Because it's been the same thing. Year, after year, aaaaafter yeeeaaarr, aaaaaaaafffffftter yyyyeeeeeaaaarrrrrr.

Number two actually is one of my top five overall most anticipated games: Gears 5. I'm a die-hard fan, and the way The Coalition decided to show this year was just baffling to me. The weird faces trailer was just an off-tone piece that felt out place. As was the trailer for Escape. The mode itself isn't for me as it requires other people, so cutting to stage theatrics and gimmicks have me concerned.

Despite my disappointment with Gears, NOTHING got on my nerves as much as The Elder Scrolls Online, and more upsetting is the fact I'm not aggravated at the game itself. The constant "WWWWOOOOOOOOOOOO" every half sentence was about the most frustrated I've ever felt during ANY E3 press conference. And I've seen some bad ones.

Alright everybody, I've FINALLY was able to get this updated! Took several hours, but it's now COMPLETELY up-to-date! (Would've been quicker, but a couple people aren't reading. Won't tag you, but I wish you would do as your fellow participants have done in the posts IMMEDIATELY above this one).

A couple of notes for you:

Because there was so much movement, I couldn't keep up with the all the movement. Also, there are five new additions from E3!

For Cadence of Hyrule, it's out tomorrow, so I've just to leave it off, as it didn't make sense to keep it up for six or seven hours.

Much like Ori from Xbox, Animal Crossing from the Direct got pushed into 2020. After posting this message, I discovered Psychonauts 2 also got pushed, as did Wrath: Aeon of Ruin.

Finally, thanks for the updates! Unless someone comes back or we get a new addition, the next update will be next week.

Wanted to quickly pop in and say to the three that have updated, I see ya! I'll update accordingly in a little while and let you know when I've done so, but also this is a public call: You want to update? Come on in!! And if you do, do as your fellow posters above and leave a note saying you did!

I've stayed out of the topic for too long because I'm so self-conscious about espousing my love for this game so much. So all I'll add is:

Yeah. I threw down the $350. Best E3 demo for me.

Speaking as someone who isn't into Nintendo, this was FANTASTIC. I am VERY pleased with this year's Direct. A lot of variety and the big N is continuing its commitment of having at least one thing for everyone, both first and third party.

Having Smash being both the start and the false end was a great way to help space their announcements. While both fighters were the most popular calls, I still enjoyed their reveals, however, in Banjo's case, it was the SAME way they did King K. Rool, and I wish it was done different only for that reason. I also appreciate the transition into Dragon Quest XI after showing Dragon Quest in Smash.

While I did bet against it, I did enjoy Bowser's intro. The reason why I bet no was I was concerned they wouldn't do it without it being corny, but it was a decent way to package it.

Luigi's Mansion 3 and Link's Awakening Remake getting the deep-dives they did were also really well done, especially the latter with a dungeon builder!

The Dark Crystal game and the focus didn't do anything for me, but watching the Allies reinforce what I said above: These will be for somebody.

The Witcher III on Switch is ridiculous in a good way. Love the fact it's coming to Switch, but I do NOT have faith it'll work well.

The segment of this direct including Fire Emblem: Three Houses, the Resident Evil 5 and 6 ports, No More Heroes 3, Contra: Rogue Corps., and Daemon X Machina was one of two low points of the show, and it wasn't really bad, speaking the high quality of this presentation.

The Panzar Dragoon project was probably the one thing from this direct that appealed to me the most, and I'm curious if this is a remake or an entirely new game. I'm very curious to learn more.

I kind of feel like the Pokemon Sword/Shield wasn't really necessary.

Astral Chain's significant trailer and the surprising Emprie of Sin (if only because John Romero is working on it) preceded the second low segment that was Marvel Ultimate Alliance 3, Cadence of Hyrule, and Mario & Sonic at the Olympic games.

However, the Direct at this point strapped a rocket ship to itself and exploded into the highest levels of hype: Animal Crossing: New Horizons first unveiling, the Banjo-Kazooie reveal, and that which no needs introduction, and what will inarguably the biggest new game announcement of the show:

Breath. of the Wild. 2.

Should've waited on recording the podcast, huh? X-D

I hit 1.5/5 on predictions, but this show was great. 9/10 and personally a tie with Square for best conference.

Sqaure-Enix crushed their show for me. This was reminiscent of Bethesda 2015: Bookends with interesting middle. However, this year was more substantial.

I've said so much, so many times, about Final Fantasy VII, and the Remake. So I'll only say I absolutely loved every single thing they showed. The two blu-rays was an eye-brow raiser, but that last trailer.... chef's kiss

Liked where the put the following trailers to start the calm down: Life is Strange 2, Crystal Chronicles, Octopath Traveler, and the Last Remnant Remastered. A little confused why a couple of those are there, but smartly placed.

The Dragon Quest segment got a healthy segment with more focus on Builders 2, and I think it worked in its favor. XI was also a nice reminder, but for what it was, another good way to order this.

The Square initiatives (Collective and Music) are very neat, and I'm curious to see both of them grow. That said, Circuit Superstars and Battalion 1944 were out-of-nowhere out-of-character reveals.

I loved seeing the KH III Re:Mind trailer, but it was the same exact one, so Square should've saved it for tonight.

ShadowBringers getting a HUGE segment wasn't a surprise. Also enjoyed seeing Yoshida onstage.

Dying Light 2 (weird publishing deal), Romancing Saga, and Final Fantasy Brave Exvius felt like another cooldown and prep for a great ramp up. Outriders was decent, building to Oninaki, building to the Final Fantasy VIII remaster.

Then the close of the reveal on Avengers. I felt this was a very nice presentation, save for no playable sequence. That said, I'm a massive fan of the actors revealed and a release date is a nice touch.

I LOVED this show for the most part. 2/5 on predictions, but EASILY the best conference of E3 this year. 9/10

This conference had nothing for me, and the pacing felt a little all over the place, but unlike the previous conferences, it was steady: Not super high, not super low.

The "non-game" things felt a little unnecessary: The Assassin's Creed Symphony, Mystic Quest, and the Uplay Plus announcement were things I didn't feel like they belonged (but this IS Ubisoft, but still....)

Watch Dogs Legion showed the best and the best part of the conference overall.

The shoutcaster introduced Rainbow Six: Siege trailer, the Brawlhalla/Adventure Time crossover, Tom Clancy's Elite Squad, and the For Honor limited time mode trailer (Shadows of the Hitokiri), all were shoulder-shrugs from me.

With the amount of talking Ghost Recon: Breakpoint and The Division 2 received, (in addition to WD: Legion), there were only THREE games that had substantial showings. That said, I wish there was more information about Rainbow Six: Quarantine

The last two games, Roller Champions and Gods & Monsters, didn't really show the games that well.

Writing all this out and going over the notes, I'm on the fence about whether Ubisoft needed to do a conference. I went 2 for 5 on predictions, but I don't know how to feel.

At the end of the day, I think 6.5/10.

Twin Mirror delayed into 2020, so it's now taken off the list. It was dead last at 43rd.

@axel I would love it if people come back, and it probably will be better to wait. Just wanted to put the PSA out there.

DOOM Eternal has finally been given a 2019 release so its now eligible. That said, I'm going to be VERY busy, so I can't update the Master Index with it (because there are some lists above with DOOM), until I can dedicate the time. And that's not happening until after E3.