Best game this gen.

When i made lists and something like that happend i usually just blanked the position and kept the rest without bumping up. That way only the points for the ineligible game are lost and the rest stays the same.

How in the world did Mafia II and Bioshock 2 not make the Top 25, that's shocking!?

My Top 8:

Mass Effect 2
Alpha Protocol
Civilization V
Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors
Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood
Mafia II
Red Dead Redemption
Bioshock 2

@dipset I only ever played the PS3 version of the game, so no idea about mods. Vanilla was fine for me but i haven't played the game since 2010 though.

The Last of Us. The first ten minutes are 10/10, the rest is a big old meh.

This is the first time that it is really tough to put together a Top 8, will have to leave off some games i really like and enjoyed playing. Honestly though Alpha Protocol should win this. :P

Story all day. I'd rather play a game that has a amazing story but plays like shit than a game that has amazing gameplay but a shit/no story.

Uncharted 3 has the best character moments of the og PS3 trilogy imo.

Last gens best game.

It's certainly the weakest game in the series but i still enjoyed it for the most part. Most annoying thing for me was the recycling Dungeons (similar to the Uncharted Wolrds in Mass Effect before). Story and Characters are fine but overall Origins and Inquisition are much better games.