Posts made by HonkedOffJohn

@Swordfish00830 make a seperate thread about this tourney to make it more organized. also spread the word to twitch chat and discord. It should be fun :)

FES is in my opinion the only way you should play this game. I was talking to someone on Discord who was playing P3P fresh off finishing Persona 5 and he was disappointed cause it was basically a visual novel. If you want that traditional Persona game go with FES.

Super Mario Sunshine easily. Love that game.

Melee would also be hype though I gotta be honest I hate playing Smash without a Gamecube controller.

Also how about those Pokemon Coliseum games. Maybe with some Pokemon Bank functionality.

@ElTorro ok that is a good compromise but the majority of the pool is newer songs and the pool will grow every week cause the stream is growing. I truly don't believe that deleting the pool will be that effective to the odds when there are always new viewers every week and their aren't that many old songs past 30 days. At the same time I don't know how Kyle feels about deleting the pool when he hasn't done it once. You could just do it anyway. Delete the pool, announce that you did and have everyone resubmit their songs. Clean slate.

And by the way I'm okay with repeat winners as long as its a fair shot everytime. No modifiers.

First ToniP you are a blessing and I love ya. You da Goat.

But you gotta understand that the fairest thing you can do is never delete the pool and never have these modifiers favoring old or new submissions.

There are people who watch the show on Youtube and can't submit music as often as a regular Twitch viewer so its important to leave that pool open. I understand wanting to purge the pool to better the odds of everyones song getting picked but if the purpose of the SoundtrackBot is to be fair randomly selected pick than you need to be fair to EVERYONE even those that are not there in chat as often as us.

And by far the absolute worse thing you can do is add anything to SoundtrackBots code that favors one pool over another pool. If 67% of the time it picks from a more recent song pool it makes an already low percentage for an older song to be so much lower. And that's just doesn't make it fair.

So you gotta decide what you want the system to be because if you want it to FAIRNESS above all else than it needs to be that 1/400 chance of getting picked cause that is letting the laws of RNG decide. Having a modifier is like having a loaded dice. Pure unfairness.

And that's why we had Velve win twice in a row. He was favored to win amongst a pool of picks that weren't up to date to the new modifier you added. Thats my two cents.

tldr: 1/400 is the fairest system. It's the system we always had and it should not change.