In case anyone was curious (like me).
My scoring was simple; 10 points to 1st, 9 points to 2nd, and so on. No points to nods. I gave 10 to both Zelda and Persona for Brad, and two points to the fighting games Kyle put at #9 in his list.
Essentially you get a top 10 of well-diversified but all highly-regarded games. Based off of what I've seen, Yakuza 0 seems higher than other 2017 round-ups (which I agree with), and Horizon seems a little lower (which I also agree with). Nier Automata seems to be one of those games that are either high up on people's lists or not on it at all.
Notable observations include:
-Mario beating Persona 5 for #2
-Resident Evil 7 looking good at #4
-Mario + Rabids, Steamworld Dig 2, and Xenoblade Chronicles 2 JUST MISSING THE CUT